Coconut Overload

Comments 21 Comments

Coconut Peanut Butter Cream Pie with Peanut Brittle

Cakes, Pies & Tarts • Tags: , , , , , , ,

Coconut Peanut Butter Cream Pie-The Duo Dishes

Facebook is a great way to find out what people are thinking. In a recent wall posting, folks answered a question regarding their favorite coconut and peanut butter recipes. We were open to anything, even a combination of the two. You’re probably wondering what people suggested. There was coconut cream pie, peanut butter brownies, icebox cookies, coconut ice cream, peanut sesame noodles, coconut shrimp, coconut meringues, peanut butter fudge, peanut butter and jelly cookies. The list went on and on. We had just received samples of Tropical Traditions’ coconut flour and coconut peanut butter, and the goal was to use them both in one recipe. All of the suggestions really helped to lead us in the perfect direction of a pie–a pie that we would submit to KCRW’s Good Food Blog Pie-a-Day section. Last year, we submitted a Pineapple Haupia Pie, but this year’s sweet would be totally different.

For a few days, we reached out to friends and other bloggers about gluten free pie crusts. With a huge bag of coconut flour on hand, it seemed like the perfect way to experiment and use it to create a crust for this pie. The coconut flour had an intoxicating aroma that made you feel like Hawaii was only a few steps away. To the touch, it feels slightly dry and crumbly. Although coconut flour is a great ingredient for baking, it cannot be substituted for all purpose or wheat flour in the same ways or measurements. For something like a pie crust, it is very important to use moisture-packed ingredients such as eggs and oils to bind the dough. Regardless, this is not a dough that can be rolled out. Instead, you must press it into the bottom and along the sides of the pie dish. Despite our best efforts, the first recipe we did use was a bit disappointing. The taste was dusty and still slightly dry with very little flavor. After having whipped up last year’s Pineapple Haupia Pie, we knew a perfect pairing would be the buttery, sweet, but not gluten free, crust that worked well that time. It’s back to the drawing board for a great gluten free pie crust.

The Tropical Traditions coconut peanut butter was a perfect addition to the filling. The peanut butter is all natural with only two ingredients, so you know there are no extra sugars and additives in there. It also has a great aroma, just like the coconut flour. The taste is rich, so a little goes a long way. Except in a peanut butter cream pie where you can probably never have too much. Finally, the peanut brittle topping was just a small touch to add crunch to a very light, fluffy pie. It’s addictive though, so if you have a thing for sweet peanuts, you just might eat it all before anyone else does.

If you’d like to win either a jar of coconut peanut butter or a bag of organic coconut flour courtesy of Tropical Traditions, here’s your chance. Leave a comment indicating which one you’d prefer and how you’d use it. You can get one extra entry by following @troptraditions on Twitter. Leave another comment indicating that you are a new follower. You have until Thursday, June 23, at 11:59 pm PST to enter. On Friday, June 24, we’ll randomly select one winner for each product.

Join the KCRW Facebook Pie Challenge and share your own pie creation. If you’re in Los Angeles, maybe you’ll even enter your pie to the 3rd Annual KCRW Good Food Pie Contest. Let us know your favorite coconut and/or peanut butter dishes too!

Coconut Peanut Butter Cream Pie with Peanut Brittle – Serves 8
1/2 cup unsalted butter, melted
3 tablespoons sugar
1 cup flour
1/4 cup mixed and unsalted nuts (pecans, walnuts, pistachios and cashews), finely chopped
1/2 teaspoon kosher salt
Zest of 1 lemon

8 ounces cream cheese, room temperature
1 cup Tropical Traditions coconut peanut butter*
1 1/2 cups powdered sugar**
1 tablespoon vanilla
3/4 cup coconut cream
1 1/2 cups heavy cream

Topping (Recipe from Joyofbaking.com)
1/2 tablespoon baking soda
1/2 teaspoon vanilla
1/2 tablespoon unsalted butter, plus more for the baking sheet
1/4 cup water
1/2 cup light corn syrup
1 cup sugar
Pinch of kosher salt
1 cup peanuts, salted

1. Make the crust first by mixing together the sugar, flour, chopped nuts, salt and lemon zest. Drizzle the butter over the dry ingredients and combine until small crumbles form. Press the crust evenly into a 9″ pie dish, prick the bottom lightly with a fork and bake in a preheated oven at 350 degrees for 15-20 minutes or until browned along the edges and the bottom. Remove from the oven and cool completely.

2. Once the crust has cooled, beat the cream cheese and peanut butter in a large bowl. Add the powdered sugar slowly until the mixture is smooth and well combined. Set aside.

3. In a separate medium bowl, beat the vanilla, coconut cream and heavy cream until the thick liquid has roughly doubled in volume. Pour the cream into the large bowl of sweetened peanut butter. Using a spatula, fold the two together until they are well mixed. Scrape the filling into the pie crust, smoothing the top with the spatula. Slide the pie dish into your refrigerator to chill for at least an hour.

4. While the pie chills and sets, start the peanut topping. Line an 11″ x 17″ baking sheet with parchment paper and rub a little butter over the length of the paper to prevent sticking. Set aside. Whisk the baking soda and vanilla together in a small bowl, then put the pat of butter on top. Set aside as well.

5. Place the water, corn syrup, sugar, kosher salt and peanuts in a medium pot and bring the mixture to a boil. Stir constantly. Pop the pot’s lid on for 1 minute, which will cause steam to dissolve any sugar on the sides. Remove the lid, then attach a candy thermometer to the side without allowing it to touch the bottom of the pot. Continue to stir until the thermometer reads 296 degrees. Remove from heat.

6. Add the baking soda, vanilla, and butter to the pot and carefully stir for another 30 seconds, being sure to watch for the rolling puff of sugar once the ingredients go in. Quickly pour the very hot and sticky liquid onto the prepared baking sheet and spread the mixture out, if desired. Allow to cool completely before breaking it into pieces.

7. Once the pie has chilled, place a few pieces of brittle into a small plastic baggie and crush with a rolling pin or wooden spoon. Immediately before serving, sprinkle the peanut brittle over the top of the pie. Serve each slice with a large piece of brittle on the side.

*You can easily substitute regular peanut butter here.

**Tropical Traditions’ coconut peanut butter is not sweet, so there is a bit more sugar in this pie than we may have used if regular peanut butter was in the mix. You can definitely decrease or increase the amount of sugar here based on your preference.

Of course we received these products for free, but we could have easily not mentioned it in any way. We’re never required to perform a review, and if we do, it does not have to be positive. These thoughts are our own. Keep that in mind FTC folks!

Click HERE for the printable recipe.

Comments Leave a Comment

Other recipes you may enjoy...

  • One Last Indulgence

    One Last Indulgence

  • Thanks Martha

    Thanks Martha

  • Floured Blueberries - The Duo Dishes

    A Very Berry Cake

  • Let Them Eat Cake

    Let Them Eat Cake

  • Peek Into This Sweet Potato Pecan Pie

    Peek Into This Sweet Potato Pecan Pie


21 Responses | TrackBack URL | Comments Feed

  1. I’m not always the biggest fan of coconut. But this looks so absolutely glorious that you have me sold. Mmm, peanut butter and coconut — another match made in heaven.


  2. YUMBO!


  3. I’ve attempted gluten free pie crust before without really good results. If you stumble across a good recipe, let me know! This pie looks fantastic though!


  4. Oh my, you guys are at it again…I think I just put on a kilo looking at the pic, and then another when I read the recipe. DIVINE!


  5. not sure how i missed this query on FB…. but i like the idea of coconut and peanut butter. but, wasn’t it too sweet?
    even still, i like the coconut peanut butter best… i’d make a kick arse French Toast (something Im so on these days) or a flan, of course!! ha. Bout to follow them and so i’ll be back to let you know!


  6. following them now…


  7. I live too far away for the giveaway but I wanted to say I love this combination. So creative!


  8. Such an interesting combination – coconut & peanut butter…but I think it could work! I love that you two are always coming up with fun and inventive pie recipes! I just wished I lived closer to try a slice here & there! Great job!


  9. Oh opps – I didn’t tell you what I would prefer…. coconut peanut butter sounds yummy!


  10. […] Coconut Overload – The Duo Dishes There was coconut cream pie, peanut butter brownies, icebox cookies, coconut ice cream, peanut sesame noodles, coconut shrimp, coconut meringues, peanut butter fudge peanut butter and jelly cookies. […]


  11. SAWOOOOOON!!! That looks heavenly. Coconut = love.


  12. We looooooove coconuts! Recently wrote an article on coconuts for my weekly food column. This looks delish (as usual coming from you guys).


  13. wow loaded with coconut…I love it. Coconut peanut butter sounds terrific.


  14. I’m not sure there is such a thing as coconut overload! This pie looks divine, now I’ll have to be on the hunt for coconut peanut butter though 🙂


  15. What an amazingly delicious looking pie. Brilliant use of the two flavors and I loved how your FB post brought out so many ideas from everyone.

    I also want to thank you for the pie crust recipe. As I have been experimenting with gluten-free baking, I do keep some coconut flour in the house. I have always been a bit afraid of doing piecrusts though. I will definitely try this one!


  16. …although maybe I shouldn’t since you said that recipe wasn’t very good. Okay. I’m torn. Take my chances with your recipes instead?


  17. You have just spoken my love language. p.s. I still read your blog, sorry for the lack of comments lately! 🙂


  18. I adore everything about coconut but have never combined it with peanut butter. Will have to get myself a jar and experiment with it in some breads. And cookies. And pies. And OH – ice cream.


  19. We’ll aren’t I a day late and a dollar – errr, entry short:) Congrats to the winner.


  20. […] With a jar of coconut peanut butter in hand, it was time to think hard about the best way to use it. The idea for a creamy, yet airy cream pie was first in line of ideas. There’s something about a cream pie that seems perfect for summer. It’s light and cool with enough sweetness to satisfy any craving for sugar. The coconut peanut butter was a lucky score this time. We received a jar in the mail, and the combination of coconuts and peanuts in one bite seemed like a sign from the pie skies to use it in a dessert. When coconut cream pie and peanut butter cream pie meet, they make a wonderful pair. You can find the full recipe for our Coconut Peanut Butter Cream Pie here. […]


  21. I don’t think I’ve seen a yummier thing. These are my two fav things…coconut and peanut butter. I wonder what this would taste like with other nut butters, like macadamia nut butter. I cant wait to try this. Thank you!


Leave a Reply

 Subscribe by RSS Follow on Twitter Like on Facebook Follow on Google+ Follow on Pinterest View on YouTube

Get post updates by Email!

Enter your email address: